Respondent Wins INDRP Case: Chiesi.in

Ceres

New Member
The respondent in this INDRP case won the right to keep the domain Chiesi.in even though it did not file a response. The complainant failed to provide sufficient evidence to support its case. A summary of the case is found below.

The complainant is Chiesi Farmaceutici S.p.A., an Italian pharmaceutical company that develops and sells pharmaceutical products worldwide.

The respondent is BrandConcern BV (based in Netherlands). It seems to be some kind of branding company which owns nearly 800 domains. A Google search reveals that this company is part of the Lambretta Consortium.

My understanding is that CHIESI is a surname. When the complainant contacted the respondent, it requested €10,000 for the domain name.

According to the complainant, after it had filed the INDRP complaint, the respondent applied for a trademark for "CHI ESI" branded goods. The complainant alleges that these are "fake" goods. There was also a brief change in the Whois but it reverted back to the original respondent.

Although the complainant owns many trademark registrations/applications worldwide that include the word CHIESI, it failed to produce evidence showing it had acquired exclusive rights in India for the word "CHIESI." The complainant argued that its main product in India is CUROSURF and that the packaging carries its CHIESI logo.

The Arbitrator stated that:

Complainant has failed to plead and establish what his right (statutory and/or common law) in India that is violated by the registration of the disputed domain name <chiesi.in>.

Therefore I refuse the Complaint for want of pleadings.
The Arbitrator had even requested additional submissions from the complainant, but these still did not contain evidence to support the complainant's case.

When I check Google's Keywords Adwords tool, neither CHIESI nor CUROSURF have a high search volume in India. Some of the "Chisei" searches relate to the complainant, however many do not.

I think this was a fair decision by the Arbitrator due to the lack of evidence by the complainant. In the past, I've been concerned that complainants have succeeded with their cases even though they failed to provide sufficient evidence showing they'd acquired exclusive rights over a name in India. Therefore, it was good to read this decision today.

What are your thoughts on this INDRP decision?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Ceres

New Member
Interestingly enough, I just read that Chiesi Farmaceutici S.p.A. won Chiesi.ch (.ch for Switzerland). As the WIPO domain name decision is in German, I found it difficult to obtain the facts of this case. However, a translation of the decision seems to indicate that the complainant had a Swiss trademark for CHIESI. The respondent did not file a response to the complaint.

The decision mentions that the complainant did not succeed in its attempt to obtain Chiesi.co.uk (I assume this was another arbitration case).
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Prashant Sharan Respondent in the UDRP case against the RosettaStone.app does to US court Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan A UDRP respondent from Australia tells WIPO panelist to “fuck off” Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Ceres Complainant Tries to Capitalise on Respondent's Reputation Legal Issues and Dispute 1
Ceres Respondent Loses 1,519 Domains in Domain Dispute Legal Issues and Dispute 1
Ceres INDRP Respondent Ordered To Pay Costs Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Mrs. Jello wins Spase.com UDRP filed in bad faith by Spase.io owner Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Atleast, TikTok wins in Ukraine Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Geico wins WIPO case Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Dow wins cybersquatting dispute against D0W .com Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Three Best Rated wins UDRP against ThreeBestRated.com.au Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Interesting !! : Konstantinos Zournas wins a GoDaddy auction but couldn't get any info on the bidder Resources 0
Prashant Sharan Domain Capital wins UDRP Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan NamesCOn 2020: Ron Jackson wins the Lonnie Borck Memorial Award Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan Naturals loses UDRP but still wins Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Silversea Cruises, Ltd. wins the UDRP for SilverSeas.com Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan AbdulBasit Makrani wins AguaDulce.com domain reverse domain name hijacking case Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Hong Kong-based DotKids Foundation wins the race for .kids New GTLDs 1
Prashant Sharan IMI.com owner wins - Jury ruled out any cyber squatting Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan .com vs ccTLDs : Who wins the face-off ? Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Amazon wins the battle against government New GTLDs 0
Prashant Sharan .com wins over new gTLDs by 2:1 in 2018 Resources 0
Prashant Sharan John Berryhill, representing complainant, wins UDRP Legal Issues and Dispute 0
JulienJ GoDaddy wins customer service award Registrars 0
JulienJ Google doesn’t respond to UDRP but still wins Legal Issues and Dispute 0
JulienJ Ritz Carlton Hotel Wins UDRP For RitzCarltonYachtCollection.Com Legal Issues and Dispute 0
JulienJ Donuts (finally) wins .Charity dispute, clearing path to .charity domain names New GTLDs 0
domainking131 John Berryhill wins Loading.com UDRP on behalf of Mrs. Jello LLC Legal Issues and Dispute 0
domainking131 Donuts wins .doctor New GTLDs 0
domainking131 : Trademark Holder Of Rocket Pay Wins RocketPays.com Loses on RocketPay.com Legal Issues and Dispute 0
domainking131 Tim Schoon : Godfather of “Chips” wins UDRP for LLLL .com Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Go Daddy Wins Court Case Most Thought They would lose Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Facebook wins facebookghana.com & fracebook.com Non-Indian Domains 0
DomainSherpa WordPress Bad Faith?; Nat Cohen Takes Frivolous UDRP to Court & Wins; Sherpas’ Oldest Domains; How t The Lounge 0
domainking131 WordPress wins another round against Chris Pearson Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Autism.Rocks Wins Weekly Sales List at $100,000 Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Mera.com Wins Weekly Sales List at $132,500 Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Google Wins Rights to Two Other New gTLDs : .Map and .Search New GTLDs 0
domainking131 Microsoft wins two Microsoft related domain names in arbitration Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Google wins five Youtube-Related domain name Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Google Wins Rights for Googlereklamekibi.com Domain Name in Arbitration Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Donald Trump wins generic domain TrumpCard.com in UDRP Non-Indian Domains 2
domainking131 CurrencyConverter.com wins weekly sales list at $150,000 Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 WordPress wins WordrPress.org domain name in Arbitration Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Donuts wins .Family New GTLDs 0
domainking131 Luxe.com wins DNJournal's weekly sales list at $172,500 Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Donuts wins three sports new gtlds: .Socker, .Hockey, .Run New GTLDs 0
domainking131 Google wins Google-Advertising-Start.com domain name in arbitration Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Google wins new gTLD .APP for $25 million New GTLDs 1
domainking131 Afilias wins the .BET new gTLD beating competitors New GTLDs 0
domainking131 TV.se wins weekly sales chart on DNJournal Non-Indian Domains 0

Similar threads

whois

Recent Posts



Forums dedicated to Indian domain names, including buying, selling, appraising, developing, and monetizing.

About Us

Threads
27,049
Messages
74,047
Members
7,646
Latest member
samir
Top Bottom