Pennsylvania law firm sues domain company

Ice

New Member
I am glad to see that people are actually taking action on these kinds of things now. I do think that their monetary consumption demands are a little high, but I do think that the domains should be shut-down or purchased by the company that owns the similar trademarks.
 

Biiome

New Member
I don't think that the company was right in suing the registrar of the domains at all. I think that it should be fine as they registrant registered the domain before the company, and I think that the company should get nothing other than a possible offer to purchase the domains if they wish to do so.
 

Ceres

New Member
I don't think that the company was right in suing the registrar of the domains at all. I think that it should be fine as they registrant registered the domain before the company, and I think that the company should get nothing other than a possible offer to purchase the domains if they wish to do so.

I don't agree that the only recourse for the law firm should have been a possible offer to purchase the domain. For example, what would be the point in registering a trademark if it offers you no protection? Also, there would be a floodgate of people demanding money from companies in exchange for trademarked domains.

But that's just my two pennies worth...
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DomainWalla

Member
Country flag
Colonial comparisons

Pennsylvania?s legal system retains peculiar ties to British colonialism that are relevant to both India and the U.S.

General the Marquess Cornwallis, the last major British military leader in what is now known as the United States, served two terms as governor general of India after his surrender in 1871 to a combined American-French force at the Siege of Yorktown.

In India he is known for instituting the permanent settlement and corresponding changes in the legal system. In the U.S. federal legal system, colonial remnants of British rule are strongest in the former proprietary colony of Pennsylvania.

In a proprietary colony, like a satrapy, the ruler can delegate sovereign authority to private parties to exercise on behalf of the ruler. This can result in the private party providing over-arching or erroneous interpretations of government policies.

In Pennsylvania, I worked for a municipality that brought suit against the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania in a case that questioned the government?s granting of a land patent to a private party. The private party represented the sovereign in the case, which was dismissed after the municipality was deemed to lack legal standing to even bring a case that challenged the sovereign?s rights to grant permissions for the use of land and waters in the Commonwealth.

In India, although Ambedkar changed the constitution, he did not change enough of the old colonial laws in India. Nor were land reforms undertaken broadly enough to reverse the legacy of Cornwallis.

Colonialism retains strange and deep-seated roots in both countries.

Legal scholars are needed who can make a proper analysis of the process of decolonization, with the results available in a format that can be applied to help push the process forward.
 

Ceres

New Member
In contrast to the Pennsylvania case mentioned above, the 65-lawyer firm of Gable Gotwals recently lost their fight to win the domain name GableGotwals.com.

The main difference between the two cases is that Gable Gotwals did not file a trademark application for their firm name. The fact that Gable Gotwals used the firm name on stationery and marketing materials was not enough to merit the transfer of the domain.

http://blog.larrybodine.com/2008/10...m-loses-web-trademark-fight-for-its-own-name/
 

Jeff

Administrator
Staff member
Country flag
The complainant could just have done a lousy job at preparing their materials.
 

Mice

New Member
Interesting read thanks! I do agree with the Judge's decision, and it's good to see that the law is on the side of companies and registrants, and not the people trying to take traffic away from companies or use their names to make money.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
I Greetings from Pennsylvania Introduce Yourself 4
Prashant Sharan Law asking Google to pay for news content can hurt small publishers Registrars 0
Jeff Good summary of ecommerce law in India Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan 4th November Market Update: $343k in Sales - Gambling-Law-Us.com sold for $57,000 Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Farrer & Co law firm couldn't win cybersquatting dispute Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan ESQwire : Domainer friendly law firm rolls out redesigned web site Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan “Stringent” censorship law could affect domain companies Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan Common law trademark used in grabbing EmLife .com, a 1996 domain Legal Issues and Dispute 0
Prashant Sharan Mountain Motorsports.com : Common law trademark not sufficient per UDRP outcome Legal Issues and Dispute 0
JulienJ What are the standards for common law trademarks in UDRP cases? Legal Issues and Dispute 0
JackD How WHOIS could survive the new EU privacy law The Lounge 1
domainking131 Bitfinex Hires Law Firm to Challenge Critics Cryptocurrencies 0
domainking131 Frank Schilling’s Brother-In-Law Made $35k In His First Year As A Part-Time Domain Investor Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Domain Investors Need To Learn Some Trademark Law Legal Issues and Dispute 1
domainking131 Global law firms targeted by Chinese cyber-squatter Legal Issues and Dispute 0
domainking131 .Law has sold and verified 6,000 domain names to law professionals New GTLDs 1
domainking131 This week’s new TLDs: .Law, .Abogado New GTLDs 0
domainking131 .Law and .Abogado(Lawyer in Spanish) will be only for Lawyers New GTLDs 1
domainking131 Afnic 50/50 law for new gTLD registrations New GTLDs 0
H Great Three Letters domain On Auction at flippa - Law.bz External Auctions 0
Jeff New Indian Domain Law Website Legal Issues and Dispute 2
A Law.tc, Law.tl, Seeing.tv, Dvd.tl, Dvd.cx, EEE.NU, External Auctions 0
Ceres Cyber Law Cartoons Legal Issues and Dispute 0
FishSEO Hot Indian Domains: Law.org.in For Sale 0
Jeff Delhi Cyber Law Advocate Legal Issues and Dispute 13
Ceres Virginia Supreme Court declares anti-spam law unconstitutional Legal Issues and Dispute 3
R domain law questions Legal Issues and Dispute 2
Jeff Indian Domain Law Legal Issues and Dispute 4
FishSEO Law.org.in & Government.org.in For Sale For Sale 0
Prashant Sharan Denmark firm found engaging in RDNH for Mountaintop.com Legal Issues and Dispute 0
domainking131 Email analytics firm 250ok scores $2.6 million Series A Business and Economy 0
anquest .ooo (letter 'o') Registry Owner + Indian eComm/'eComm Enabler' Firm INFIBEAM Started Trading Today General Indian Domain Name Discussion 1
anquest 15.ooo Sells @ $3K (India-based eCommerce firm Infibeam is the .ooo Registry Owner) | SEDO Sales General Indian Domain Name Discussion 0
anquest 11.ooo Sells For $3K / Registry Owner >> India-based eComm firm Infibeam | SEDO Sales General Indian Domain Name Discussion 1
domainking131 Giuseppe Graziano launches Domain Brokerage firm GGRG.com Resources 2
the_poet Casino.firm.in For Sale 0
anquest .ooo | Indian e-commerce firm Infibeam places a full page ad in 'The Times of India' New GTLDs 0
D health.firm.in -----> health, an evergreen domain name For Sale 0
C art.firm.in Domain Appraisals 2
C seo.firm.in - chance to grab SEO domain for 100 bucks For Sale 1
C map.firm.in and maps.firm.in For Sale 0
Will .firm.in questions General Indian Domain Name Discussion 5
D Value of org.in / firm.in / gen.in / ind.in General Indian Domain Name Discussion 17
D Good firm.in Domains For Sale 9
C Security.firm.in Betting.firm.in Domain Appraisals 15
D match.firm.in, match.gen.in For Sale 0
M dvd.firm.in For Sale 1
A Looking for LLL.ins with all premiums and keywords.in for a firm price. Domains Wanted 7
skyshipper blog.firm.in For Sale 0
anquest ipv6.firm.in - buy it now $1,000 or best offer For Sale 0

Similar threads

whois

Recent Posts



Forums dedicated to Indian domain names, including buying, selling, appraising, developing, and monetizing.

About Us

Threads
26,913
Messages
73,889
Members
7,639
Latest member
rohanarya2612
Top Bottom