There are two sides to every story (or coin) - fair and equitable laws are essential. Archaic laws simply amended on a reactive basis are as dangerous as NO LAW at all (LAWLESSNESS). Also specifics and implementation is KEY to being fair and equitable. While the counsel for Key Systems said that if the ruling is not over turned this could lead possibly to the whole business model being endangered.
Here are two key paras and MY KEY highlighted terms (question is what is the specifics and threshold of tolerance - 36 hours may be enough to determine violation but sufficient and irrefutable evidence is a must):
Universal had wanted to prevent unauthorized distribution of Robin Thicke’s album Blurred Lines, said Volker Greimann, Key-Systems’ general counsel, in an email.While Key-Systems argued that it was not responsible for the copyright infringement, the court ruled that the registrar had a duty to investigate after notification of infringing activity and had to take corrective action in case of obvious violations, Greimann said.
If someone notifies the registrar of a clear violation of the law, it must examine the specific allegation immediately and close the domain if necessary, the court ruled.