WTF Idea To Tackle Scam Websites? More Red Tape

CyberKing

Domain Investor
Country flag
Currently, a 15-member panel appointed by the government to recommend amendments to the Information Technology Act, 2000 – the country’s primary law dealing with cybercrime – and bring cyber security under its ambit is deliberating on the prospect of a government registry for all domain names generated in India. Other than government officials, the panel consists of bankers and cyber security experts. The proposal for a registry for domain names was tabled at its meeting in October.

“Having a government registry for domains and recording basic details about the individuals procuring those domains can help investigation of crimes to a great extent,” said a member of the panel. “It is a proposal which the panel members are still deliberating on. The process of control on domain names is not supposed to end with the registry. It is also supposed to include scrutiny and periodic verification of domain names in order to regularly identify the dubious ones.”
https://scroll.in/article/856043/as...r-indian-internet-domains-may-be-in-the-works
 

marsh

Active Member
I'd like to hear your thoughts on this. Cyber crime is advancing each day and I think more people are falling prey to these fake websites. In my view, more attention should be paid to making people more knowledgeable and tech-savvy.
 

CyberKing

Domain Investor
Country flag
There is a reason why I shared this article with all in the domain community, suprised with the muted response, guess no one cares about the implications. What got me with this half baked reporting or article was this:

a) Whenever I hear a 15 Member Panel - visualize me as such, arms akimbo and smoke coming out of my ears, ever heard of such a panel making rational choices, no - so there goes one strike
b) Notice how the so called cybersec expert is not named? If you have been watching the Digital India initiative and other payments breach related news over the last year, you could perhaps guess who this individual is...another also ran IMO with no depth or background in the subject matter and with a vested commercial interest milking the wave. So with zero credibility strike two
c) Now there is NO NEED to REINVENT the wheel and create another MONSTER database when you have a QUASI GOV ORG to administer the existing database. The issue is POOR GOVERNANCE FRAMEWORK, INFRASTRUCTURE and IMPLEMENTATION by NIXI (at the risk of sounding a NIXI Basher instead of a well wisher, which I actually am I have been raising this for years) So more Red Tape, hence strike three.

Now as far as bogus scam sites and fraudulent domain owners etc. yes awareness aside enforcement by responsible parties needs to be made with accountability. We have the laws, we always had dismal implementation.

Here is an example of how the ccTLD .us enforces ownership checks: http://www.about.us/policies/ustld-nexus-requirements

Now this link is about the "legal requirements for ownership" which IMO is well laid out and a stringent framework. However enforcement is the key, and the Registrar is held accountable. Similarly for websites and content the Hosting provider should fulfill all KYC Norms. For Social Media obviously the networks are held accountable. In relevant cases the ISPs (or gateways) are held accountable, example emails fradulent payments etc. This will increase the cost of operations and procedural burdens that accompany such a step - however the ecosystem needs to be made "secure and trustworthy" and prevention is better than cure for sure.

Overarching all this several institutions and acts exist already to ensure security across all geos in the world. Those institutions or governing bodies must act swiftly when at lower levels there is a breach i.e. quick escalation path should be well defined.

Here is where I have had an issue with existing systems and institutions in India, slow and "sarkari" having near zero response and redressal mechanisms (99% of emails get ignored - just an email address on the website is not a mechanism, no audit no accountability no system)!

So, if the panel has its way, if this article is factual I dread a monster database, to monitor another monster database which is nothing but red tape and serves no purpose.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Prashant Sharan Redbull uses ".WTF" domain name for a major Berlin event New GTLDs 0
CyberKing WTF - INDRP? Legal Issues and Dispute 0
DomainSherpa omainSherpa Discussion: Fail.WTF?; Visa Drops V.me; Google Domains; DomainTools... The Lounge 0
Ceres WTF: Wisconsin Tourism Federation The Lounge 0
Prashant Sharan Flatten.ca: A great Domain + idea Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Uniregistry's unique domain sales idea: Missed connections! Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Out of the Box idea for Domain & Brand Exposure Resources 0
Prashant Sharan Neustar and .Biz domains seems to like the idea of no price caps!! Registrars 0
E How a business idea on the blockchain can help you grow your business Webmaster Forum 2
domainking131 How to Validate Your Start-Up Idea Using Landing Pages Webmaster Forum 0
A Is it a bad idea to buy Hindi domain names now? General Indian Domain Name Discussion 0
F 188772.com, Idea-Bank.com, GotCo.com | NJ External Auctions 0
D Topic Idea Generator Webmaster Forum 0
S Web design Idea for Ecommerce site Webmaster Forum 2
domainking131 Newly funded startups and their domain names: Idea.com, DigitalAsset.com, Waldo.photos Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 The Donuts Story: From an idea to 1 million registrations New GTLDs 1
domainking131 New business idea- $5000 a month Resources 0
domainking131 Get a rough idea of your Domain's worth!! General Indian Domain Name Discussion 0
DomainSherpa Rapid Prototyping to Test Your Business Idea for Free on Facebook – With Raj Beri The Lounge 0
ImageAuthors Landrusher.com & Landrushers.com ... Got an idea for the new GTLD Land Rush? Non-India Related Domains 0
DNJournal.com How Bill Karamouzis Plans to Change the World With a Big Idea and a Bold Domain Buy Non-Indian Domains 0
C Is it a good idea to register some simple words like the followings General Indian Domain Name Discussion 6
G Share with me your idea (important) General Indian Domain Name Discussion 8
O iam.in - any development idea? pls share :) General Indian Domain Name Discussion 2
anquest NetBook.CENTER Sells @ EUR 4K (appx. US$4,442) / Tackle.DIRECT $2.5K / Earth.SCIENCE $2.5K New GTLDs 0

Similar threads

whois



Forums dedicated to Indian domain names, including buying, selling, appraising, developing, and monetizing.

About Us

Threads
27,057
Messages
74,056
Members
7,646
Latest member
samir
Top Bottom