Why .IN domains should have more Free and Open Aftermarket in India

Discussion in 'General Indian Domain Name Discussion' started by Aubits, Jun 5, 2017.

  1. Aubits

    Aubits United States Active Member

    Joined:
    Sep 9, 2009
    Messages:
    190
    Likes Received:
    134
    Trophy Points:
    43
    Having been an investor and enthusiast of .IN domains since 2005, have to tell you the growth of .IN registrations have been good but could be a lot better. India is a country that has a great future ahead and there is tremendous energy in growth of ecommerce, startups, high speed broadband , always ON internet and so forth, yet few people are making the connection in media to .IN domains. There is hardly any coverage in Indian media on .IN domain names, most people seem to understand .COM for obvious reasons, but mention of .IN is visibly absent. There could be many reasons but I would like to point out a few that are very clear to many of the domain investors. Let's look at a comparison between .COM and .IN.

    ---------------------------------------------------------

    .COM

    Versign Registry

    - Open to anyone in the world

    - Aftermarket is Free and Open which includes Registrars like Godaddy and others, Aftermarket Companies like Sedo, Namejet, Afternic and so forth. Domain name auctions are sponsored by Verisign

    - Domainer rights and disputes governed by UDRP process. Process is much fairer to domainers

    ---------------------------------------------------------------

    .IN

    NIXI Registry

    - Open to anyone in the world. No residency requirements

    - Aftermarket is restricted to individuals and corporations. Not open to Regsitrars. No auctions in India by Indian companies operating on .IN domain

    - Domainer rights and disputes governed by INDRP. Domainers believe the rights are far lower than .COM

    ------------------------------------------------------------------

    .IN having no residency requirements is a huge positive in making it available throughout the world and there are registrants in almost 200 countries. Now the areas of improvement would need to come in Aftermarket reform. Having many restrictions and contradictory/confusing actions over the years since 2005 has ended up with no aftermarket companies in India that operate on .IN domain. This has put .IN domainers at a disadantage and directly helps .COM domains. .COM has been a leader with over 130 million registrations and my suggestion would be to closely study the .COM registry's path and see how .IN could follow a similar path to openness. Such reforms would not only help open up the market by encouraging startups in India and have many existing investors, companies particularly registrars be involved in the aftermarket.

    A healthy and thriving aftermarket is essentialf for the growth of .IN market and ecosystem. Opening up and having a free market will increase .IN domain valuations which is essential for .IN domain registrants. (Do you know of anyone who will by any property that does not appreciate in value? Will anyone buy property that cannot be sold freely?). These are some of the issues I believe hindering further growth of .IN. What this has done is provide web developers in India to recommend other options such as .COM and even some new gtlds. So the option for .IN is very clear, open up the aftermarket with no restrictions and .IN domainers and registrants will feel they have equal footing to .COM domainers and registrants. .IN cannot compete with .COM with such handicap that currently exists and .COM is only going to grow.

    Having an active aftermarket ensures domain owners can have potential exit plans for their domains and business, brings in more investments to the market, thereby increasing the visibility of .in domains to other business. It will feed off each other and there will be more research and studies conducted by these aftermarket companies that would be valuable for domain industry in India. Currently, there is hardly any domain data or research conducted or available for .IN domain owners. Such data being open will only help the transparency of the .IN market. All of these will positively impact the industry and will be in line with India's growth as an economic power.

    In regards to domainer rights, the currrent perception is that .IN domainers have much lower rights than .COM domain owners, that needs to change for .IN to effectively grow. The earlier those reforms are implemented, the better.

    Note: This is meant as an honest assessment of the current situation in regards to .IN domain names based on my interactions with other domain investors and my over 20 years experience with .com domain names.
     
  2. Jeff
    • Staff / Moderator

    Jeff Canada Administrator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Mar 26, 2008
    Messages:
    4,639
    Likes Received:
    650
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Excellent post - thanks! I agree with much of what you say, including your recommendations. I'm not sure how quickly that will happen though.
     
    RajG, JackD and Aubits like this.
  3. wot

    wot Thailand Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2007
    Messages:
    1,828
    Likes Received:
    182
    Trophy Points:
    63
    Good post.

    However, I don't think the Sedo .in auction is going to to help the cause much.

    But as I said before, I hope I am wrong and that it is a huge success.