The proof that .IN is a global TLD

kussy

Member
From what you wrote, you meant endusers whose business has something to do with India. I'm saying people living somewhere else in the world who have nothing to do with India may find .IN the perfect extension for their new Internet effort. IN needs both kinds of users.
"you meant endusers whose business has something to do with India"
Really? where did I hint that? I may have meant to say end users who already have a business elsewhere and are now looking to target India!

"I'm saying people living somewhere else in the world who have nothing to do with India may find .IN the perfect extension for their new Internet effort"

There are a few hundred tlds out there! People may find many more extensions perfect for their venture.
 

Dman

New Member
If you don't think it's global, you're missing a bet. And which one did you get? hosting or domains? :)
Neither. The buy was unreported and should it be resold, it will be likewise unreported.

Outside.in uses .in as a preposition, did you get that point? Now try this with your domain - hosting.in/USA or hosting.in/Germany or even hosting.in/Cloud and you'll begin to see what I'm trying to show there. I agree that one domain does not an extension make, here are some more references: .IN Developed .IN / .CO.IN Showcase - NamePros.com & Site Rank You can choose to ignore what you see, or you can open your eyes an absorb everyone's experience and then evaluate it for your own requirements, your call.
Again, cute theory- no evidence that anyone cares, or is about to start caring to any meaningful degree.

As far as developed .in sites, a lot of the stuff in that thread is domainer minisite garbage, or clearly targeting the India market. Very little speaks to your point. Yes, someone may use it as a cute hack, but that's just as irrelevant to the .in namespace as the sale of famo.us is to the .us namespace. Anecdotes.

That's because you're thinking of the past, not of the future. Kids going online after 2013 will be familiar with .word extensions, unlike our generation, which has been .com trained.
No, I'm not thinking of the past. We both agree that there is a great deal of 'change' to be had, but there's no evidence that any of it will follow the trajectory you're suggesting. That's the central point.

I'll give a very contemporary example of how 'domainer theory' can be irrelevant in the real world...

There are any number of extensions that align with US state abbreviations. .ca, .mn, .md, .la, etc, etc, etc... and no one really cared (there are some anecdotes, but no evidence).

When .co came about and marketed itself heavily to domainers, suddenly, it being used for "COLORADO!" became a standard refrain. So, what was different this time? Why was .co going to catch for Colorado when every other extension that represented the exact same thing hadn't yet mattered to anyone? The answer is, nothing changed. A typical case of dumb domainers making dumb 'theories' to justify their lighting money on fire.

Most people can be categorized into one of two groups.

Left Brainers; the analysts. They are all facts, all data and from that information, their decisions are made. Their strength is that they are tremendous at quantifying and making very lucid decisions based on the here and now, but their weakness is that they're usually awful at seeing what's up ahead. They're also not very creative.

Then, there are the right brainers.
These are the creative ones. The more intelligent right brainers can be very talented at drawing abstract conclusions, which is the skill-set required to make guesses into 'the future'. Their strength is just that- they tend to see outcomes (typical or a-typical) that the left-brainers aren't wired to process. Their weakness is that often times, their imaginations get out of control and they start to invest their beliefs in theories, without bothering to consider plausibility.

That's what we have here.

I've always said the left side of the dot is more important than the right, believe it or not. [ The Extension Agnostic | mwzd.com ] And if you're going to get a crappy keyword, even having the .com at the end won't help you.
It depends on what you're trying to do... If your objective is to splog or make minisites, then sure... I guess. If your objective is to resell, then no. If your objective is to build a meaningful enterprise then no, the extension is very important. Domainers posess no unique wisdom that the world of business- who considers ccTLDs and .com to be the irrevocable gold standard- does not posses. It's the vote of business that counts- not the vote of domainer-logic- and their vote is quite clear.

Yes, I'm saying it does. As also usage for subdirectory/subdomain hacking. GamesForGirls.com didn't go for $500k on because it looks pretty, there is a linguistic logic to it, as there is to all branding and .in just works a LOT better than .tw or .co.uk for international usage.
GamesForGirls.com went for $500K because Kara is a guy who understands significant development, the role domains play in marketing, the value of type-in traffic and actually turning a profit with an online enterprise. People like Bill operate free from the contamination of domainer psuedo-logic, which is a logic that loses considerably more money than it makes.

Actually, as of today the rest of the world has more money invested in .IN than Indians. Plus you can be sure the people spending $x,xxx or more on .in domains are mostly NOT based in India. Chew on that for a bit.
Yes. I've made a XXXX .in purchase and I'm not in India, I read something somewhere where German domainer ownership of the .in ccTLD is enormously disproportionate. This has nothing to do with Germans using .in domains in Germany (anecdotes aside). It has to do with Germans, like Americans, disproportionately active domain speculators.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

mwzd

New Member
Again, cute theory- no evidence that anyone cares, or is about to start caring to any meaningful degree.
Fair enough, but our theories and the choices we make from them are what lead our investment focus. I personally invest in domains that can be used to create a brand around, irrespective of the extension.

Very little speaks to your point.
As far as speaking to the point of foreign usage / development for .in domains I'm going to refer you back to the google language search links I listed in a previous post in this thread.

No, I'm not thinking of the past. We both agree that there is a great deal of 'change' to be had, but there's no evidence that any of it will follow the trajectory you're suggesting. That's the central point.
The average 'domainer' interest was in .co.in over .in when I started out in 2007. Being ahead of the curve has actually helped me increase my roi exponentially to what it would have been as a follower. While I can't claim to be accurate all the time, the general direction I foresee based on my experience is usually what comes to pass and I usually go with my gut, hasn't let me down so far.

That's what we have here.
If your theory is that I'm a right brainer, you're probably right. But that doesn't mean that its the sole orb I use for decision making, you might be surprised at the numbers I crunch before I make any buying decisions, it's not all 'hope' if that's what you're worried about.

It depends on what you're trying to do... If your objective is to splog or make minisites, then sure... I guess. If your objective is to resell, then no. If your objective is to build a meaningful enterprise then no, the extension is very important. Domainers posess no unique wisdom that the world of business- who considers ccTLDs and .com to be the irrevocable gold standard- does not posses. It's the vote of business that counts- not the vote of domainer-logic- and their vote is quite clear.
Splogs, minisites are one step up from parked domains, both of which do little to contribute to the internet experience beyond maybe allowing people to find something they wouldn't even know to look for, which actually can be a considered a 'legitimate use' as well, after all, isn't that what google does?

And when you say 'meaningful development' I think you're targeting an ecosystem that the domain community services, the end users.

Just for the record, I'm primarily an advertising guy and understand only too well what a client wants. Domainer logic is not something I subscribe to, nor do I 'love' or 'hate' any extension. But I think the close minded approach to online branding that people have (.com or local ccTLD) is about ready for a sea change and as an investor I don't want to have to approach the buying process from the wrong end, that's when you'd probably see me selling.

GamesForGirls.com went for $500K because Kara is a guy who understands significant development, the role domains play in marketing, the value of type-in traffic and actually turning a profit with an online enterprise. People like Bill operate free from the contamination of domainer psuedo-logic, which is a logic that loses considerably more money than it makes.
Let's be realistic here, 99% of online projects probably have $500k as their entire lifecycle valuation target, most wouldn't / couldn't / shouldn't be even considering a $500k layout just for the domain.

The 1% who do enterprise development and monetization can afford to spend that for the domain alone and justify it financially as well, but how many of us have domains that subscribe to this market. And those of us that do would probably sell way before 500k, what percentage of people have the guts to negotiate that high?

Yes. I've made a XXXX .in purchase and I'm not in India, I read something somewhere where German domainer ownership of the .in ccTLD is enormously disproportionate. This has nothing to do with Germans using .in domains in Germany (anecdotes aside). It has to do with Germans, like Americans, disproportionately active domain speculators.
You can't seriously assume that there is an Indian market for a German site written in German?

I must thank you for your insights and perspectives, it's been an interesting conversation and one that I've thoroughly enjoyed as it helped exercise my grey cells, always invigorating.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
JulienJ Call for Donuts to Release Proof of Original “Record Breaking” gTLD Sale in Late 2017 New GTLDs 0
s51888 Traffic Indian domain - AddUrl.org.in (USD 100) >10K visitors/month - Proof attached For Sale 0
D Making defamatory allegations without proof General Indian Domain Name Discussion 3
D proof of ownership Legal Issues and Dispute 7
Ceres Are Domain Names Recession Proof? Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan April 2, 2020 at 11 AM Eastern : Sedo and InterNetX to Host Global Domain Report Webinar Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan John Colascione: Global Epidemic opens up an unusually great opportunity to buy Domain Names Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Chinese Domains: China has 21 of the top 50 global sites when it comes to Alexa Rank Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan How Zhubajie.com helped Chinese company go global Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Namescon Global 2020 agenda Resources 0
Prashant Sharan Escrow Pay API gets integrated into the IPv4.Global marketplace Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan Afilias buys the other half of .global registry - its one of the new gTLD back-end customers Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan Afilias now has .Global top level domain name in its hold Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan Verisign Q1 Report : Global Domain Registrations Increases By 18 Million Resources 0
Prashant Sharan Global domain name growth slows down Resources 0
Prashant Sharan China's Global Digital Summit Returns to Xiamen Resources 0
Prashant Sharan Hilco Streambank: From IPv4Auctions.com to IPv4.Global New GTLDs 0
Prashant Sharan NamesCon Global 2019's Trend Report - The Next Best Thing Resources 0
CyberKing Showcase - A dot IN Global Brand Site (Only.IN) General Indian Domain Name Discussion 0
domainking131 Global Jobcoin Sells 10 Million Tokens in Presale & Starts Crowdsale Cryptocurrencies 0
domainking131 Global law firms targeted by Chinese cyber-squatter Legal Issues and Dispute 0
anquest Bangalore TOPS Jones Lang LaSalle's 'City Momentum Index' / 6 Indian Cities in the GLOBAL TOP 30 Business and Economy 0
anquest Sold@$4.8K Each >> DSI.GLOBAL / Open.GLOBAL / RDH.GLOBAL / SOL.GLOBAL / UMA.GLOBAL | DNJ TOP 20 New GTLDs 0
domainking131 .Global domains turn 2 years old (average premium domain sales price is $2,751) New GTLDs 1
domainking131 Summary of Global Domain Summit in Hangzhou, China The Lounge 0
domainking131 XT.com sells for seven figures at The Global Domain Summit Non-Indian Domains 1
domainking131 Canon.com now redirects to Global.Canon New GTLDs 1
domainking131 .London & .NYC Start Global #BestDotCity Campaign New GTLDs 0
domainking131 InterNetX and registries team up for auction during WHD.global Non-Indian Domains 0
M Top keyword global domains for business Non-India Related Domains 1
domainking131 XYZ to put global block on domains banned in China Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 GoDaddy Announces Global Hot 100 List of Top WordPress Plugins and Themes Non-Indian Domains 0
anquest Royal.IN Sells For $5.5K, Enelint.GLOBAL $2.75K, City.CHURCH $1.999K, Cumulus.GLOBAL $1K; SEDO Sales General Indian Domain Name Discussion 0
W India On The Curve: Has 4% Of All Global Registrations The Lounge 2
anquest Soap.CLUB Sells For $5,000 | Advent.GLOBAL For $1,500 | The DN Journal Weekly TOP 20 Sales New GTLDs 0
domainking131 Mali offers free .ML domain names in Malaysia aiming a global presence Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 .Global released 3,500 domains and ran a $25 cashback promotion New GTLDs 0
CyberKing Google Domains - LAUNCHED! USA version live - global expansion coming soon! Registrars 0
domainking131 Sydney joins global cities as applications open for its own gTLD New GTLDs 0
anquest Jobs.GLOBAL Sells For $15,000​ ​ | The DN Journal Weekly TOP 20 Non-Indian Domains 0
CyberKing India seeks global e-commerce tax rules ahead of G20 meeting The Lounge 0
CyberKing Global Internet Population and Penetration (2011 World Bank data) The Lounge 0
domainking131 35 premium .Global names sold in Auctions New GTLDs 0
domainking131 .Global in its Sunrise period New GTLDs 0
domainking131 .Press gTLD for global journalism New GTLDs 0
CyberKing Global Brands - Do not seem to use a .IN address when advertising in India! The Lounge 4
CyberKing ICANN Publishes WHOIS Primer – Global Whois Lookup Tool In Development Non-Indian Domains 0
DNJournal.com Webfest Global: Why the Conference Set Sail With a New Name and a Different Game The Lounge 1
DNJournal.com Event Queen Jodi Chamberlain Expands Domain With Launch of Global Executive Network The Lounge 0
E HindiNews.co.uk for offers - 550,000 global exact searches with low competition For Sale 1
Similar threads


















































whois



Forums dedicated to Indian domain names, including buying, selling, appraising, developing, and monetizing.

About Us

Threads
26,095
Messages
72,878
Members
7,593
Latest member
ThurmanKes
Top Bottom