The Pricing/Valuation Of It All

Swisslist

Member
In our opinion, what exactly, if anything, determines the value/price of a domain name as seen through its extension?

Everything I have seen on this topic tells me there is no method at all to the madness.
 

dibon

Member
I believe that you can get many answers to this question, based on many factors that make every domain out there (irrespective of the extension) different in its own way. You will never get any justification for a owner looking to sell a domain for $2,000 if 8 years ago, they bought it for say, $1,000. I stand corrected but I don't think there's a 'shoe that fits all', in this case.
 

JackD

Active Member
Country flag
The only thing that determines the value/price of a domain name is what a buyer is willing to pay for it. I agree with @dibon that there is not a "one size fits all" solution. Experience in selling domains and setting prices can help but it is not a guarantee of getting the price you ask. There are so many domains listed for sale for $x,xxx that I would not give the price of a reg fee for it. Doesn't mean that sometime, somewhere someone would pay the asking price, just means I would not. There is no hard and fast rule as in most pricing schemes. I just read about a domain name that was purchased in 2008 for $55,000 just sold on SEDO for less than $3000. What made the value different? Just what a buyer was willing to pay and what the owner was willing to accept.
 

tulip

Active Member
I love your last illustration @JackD about the domain that was eventually sold for $3000 or thereabouts. Could we then add that in addition to what a buyer is willing to pay, how much a seller is willing to sell a domain at still matters? If, as a seller, I feel that whatever price a prospect has quoted is peanuts, then I could possibly hold onto it until better offers come?
 

JackD

Active Member
Country flag
how much a seller is willing to sell a domain at still matters?
It does matter because if the seller is not willing to "give the domain away" for the peanuts being offered then it will not sell. But the question was about valuation. Let's say I have a domain that I think is worth $10,000 and I am not willing to accept any offers under that. Now, 10 years later I have turned down 7 offers of $3000 or less and I still have the domain paying reg fees each year, what is the "real" value of the domain? I could argue that to me it is worth $10,000 but in reality it has not been worth more than $3000. Now if it is a single keyword .com domain under 12 characters and I am willing to hang on to it, then it could be said that the domain is actually worth the $10,000. That is why domain evaluations are so hard to get right, Everybody has an opinion and there is not a scale to pin it down as in other sale items. Real Estate comes as close the the same issue as Domains than any other product I can think of. The difference is we are "trained" to believe that real estate agents can give us the correct price but not many in the domain business has that kind of experience that we are willing to listen to them. So, let's say that 80% of a domain's value is determined by what a buyer is willing to pay and 20% percent by what a seller is willing to take for it.
 

dibon

Member
I think I now get the idea here @JackD, that the buyer is the one that actually has the upper hand in these matters. Allow me to indulge you further and wonder, what if the asking price for a domain is $10,000 and 9 out of 10 prospective buyers think it is worth less than $2,000 but then the remaining person goes ahead and meets the asking price, what would be the valuation?
 

JackD

Active Member
Country flag
9 out of 10 prospective buyers think it is worth less than $2,000 but then the remaining person goes ahead and meets the asking price, what would be the valuation?
Then the value would be $10,000 because you only need one buyer who agrees to pay the price. It really boils down to this: If you think the domain is worth $10,000, are you willing to hold on to it for 10+ years in the hopes of getting $10,000 for it? I know that we all want to flip our domains fast and make the big dollars, but buyers who can afford $xx,xxx and are willing to pay that price are not plentiful. So the final valuation of a domain name is twofold, what a buyer is willing to pay and a seller is willing to accept. Putting an exact dollar amount on that domain is extremely difficult. As sellers, we all think we have great domains and that they are worth a lot of money. Buyers are just the opposite, they think the domain is okay and not worth the asking price. I find that if I have a domain for several years and have not found a buyer, then I may have to face reality and lower my price. However, if I do my research and I feel that my valuation is correct, then I will hold on to that domain until I can get my price. But I advise that you re-evaluate at least once a year so that the example I gave above ($55,000 in 2008 but less that $3000 in 2017) does not happen to you. Loosing $52,000 over nine years is not something we want to happen to anyone. We do not know the history of that domain. Maybe the buyer who paid $55,000 turned down an offer of $65,000 or $75,000 the next year because he thought it was worth more but then for whatever reason the value went down considerably. We just don't know. As best as I can remember when reading about the sale, the domain was never developed into a revenue generating website.

This whole domain pricing thing would be easier if we had a chart to go by but that is not the case. Only experience can help you with putting a real valuation on a domain. Check the sales on NameBio for similar domains and see at what price they have been selling. If it is a niche domain, what have other domains in the same niche have been selling for. I am really amazed that some of the domainers I know want to snatch prices out of thin air then don't understand why their domains do not sell.
 

dibon

Member
That is quite an explanation @JackD and I had no idea that there are people that are few people willing to meet a five-figure valuation for a purchase. I believe that all this gets better with experience. Thanks so much for this.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
ajf7688 160 .in domains for sale (Fixed Pricing + Discounts Available) For Sale 0
Prashant Sharan Developments in the .org pricing scandal Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Flippa changed their pricing AGAIN! For Sale 0
Prashant Sharan Verisign might get its billion-dollar .com pricing windfall Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan Step by step procedure to setup domain name pricing at DAN Resources 0
Prashant Sharan ICANN demystifies how .org pricing decision was made Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan DNW PodCast: Domain pricing with Jeffrey Gabriel Resources 0
Prashant Sharan Morgan Linton on re-pricing your .COM domains after the Voice.com sale Non-Indian Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Flippa changes to a new pricing model Non-India Related Domains 0
Prashant Sharan Unity emerging up and against .ORG Pricing Registrars 0
Prashant Sharan ICANN puts an end to Adobe Connect over security, pricing Registrars 0
DomainFQ.com BicyclePricing.com | Bicycle Pricing | Non-India Related Domains 1
JulienJ Avoid These Four Common Mistakes When Pricing Domains Resources 0
Jeff Great article - domain pricing Resources 2
domainking131 Domain pricing game: Acquisition middlemen still going strong in 2017 The Lounge 0
JackD Domain Name Pricing: Is it Ethical? General Indian Domain Name Discussion 1
domainking131 The Pricing of Internet Domain Names Looks Kind of Random Non-Indian Domains 5
D Difference in renewal pricing of .in domain names at Resellerclub Registrars 3
domainking131 Donuts Will Decrease Pricing for New .BUSINESS and .COMPANY Domains Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 SnapNames backorder pricing increases to $79 Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 .blog launch date and pricing revealed New GTLDs 1
domainking131 Uniregistry Goes To EAP Pricing Up to $28,500 For .MOM New GTLDs 0
domainking131 Domain economy : Dot .Net pricing inches up Non-Indian Domains 0
domainking131 Famous Four Media opens tiered pricing in 4 more domain extensions New GTLDs 0
domainking131 The Psychology of Pricing: A Gigantic List of Strategies Resources 0
CyberKing Domain Pricing Tools Domain Appraisals 4
R Please help me with this domain's pricing Domain Appraisals 2
Rajat Pricing comparison of general customer and reseller account at Mitsu General Indian Domain Name Discussion 7
indy Domparison - compare domain pricing for .in and all extensions... General Indian Domain Name Discussion 1
B onlinedegree.in Yours thoughts pls on singular and plural domain name pricing Domain Appraisals 6
ebiz4india Premium TAX Domains at affordable pricing For Sale 0
mobile INR going Down Domain Pricing Going Up The Lounge 4
ebiz4india .IN SALE - Low Pricing For Sale 2
ebiz4india .IN Mega SALE with pricing For Sale 1
ebiz4india ePhone.in + eProduct.in - Very Low Pricing For Sale 2
ebiz4india .IN Mega Sale @ Wholesale Pricing For Sale 0
ebiz4india DubaiCity, DubaiProperties & Filipino - Low Pricing For Sale 0
R NEW .IN Pricing For Renewal/Transfer General Indian Domain Name Discussion 5
ebiz4india KEYWORD DOMAINS ... Low Pricing For Sale 0
ebiz4india CollegeCampus.in & Many More - LOWEST Pricing. For Sale 0
ebiz4india Crazy Pricing - Killer Domains - From $10 Each. Hurry up.! For Sale 2
ebiz4india DNBroker.in - HomeComputer & Others @ Reasonable Pricing - Fresh List of .IN For Sale 0
ebiz4india Lowest Pricing Ever Offered for .IN domains - Check this Portfolio - $5 Each Domain. For Sale 1
D **nnn.in*** sale *new pricing* For Sale 17
ebiz4india $10 SALE for .IN Domains - One Word Domains, Cheap Pricing - 5**** For Sale 3
ebiz4india Biggest One Word .IN Domain Sale Thread. Cheap Pricing. Quality Domains. For Sale 2
O Domain pricing, £5.98 per year for .com! For Sale / Advertising 0
ebiz4india GR8 Domain +Low Pricing: BusinessTax.in - ShareBrokers, SaleTax, EquityFund, Payouts For Sale 2
Jeff .IN hits 600,000 Domains + Promo Pricing to Continue until September General Indian Domain Name Discussion 4
ebiz4india One Word Adult Domains for Sale, very Low Pricing! - URGENT SALE Adult Domains 0
Similar threads


















































whois



Forums dedicated to Indian domain names, including buying, selling, appraising, developing, and monetizing.

About Us

Threads
26,117
Messages
72,903
Members
7,593
Latest member
ThurmanKes
Top Bottom