As you probably know, Estibot is currently working on EstiBot v.2. I decided to compare the appraisals of a few Indian domain names using Estibot v.1 and Estibot v.2.

I entered the top 10 reported Indian domain sales (using 'Bulk Appraisal' on v1, and 'Domain Name Appraiser' on v2). Here are the results:

Poker.in – v2: $8,800 (v1: $5,800)
Mails.in – v2: $25,000 (v1: $12,000)
Searching.in - v2: $1,900 (v1: $460)
Linkshare.in - v2: $720 (v1: $140)
Webcam.in - v2: $19,000 (v1: $11,000)
Defend.in - v2: $9,700 (v1: $4,800)
Tea.in - v2: $5,400 (v1: $13,000)
Leds.in - v2: $8,200 (v1: $4,100)
123.in – v2: $7,700 (v1: $4,200)
Hollywood.co.in – v2: $7,200 (v1: did not recognise this third level domain)

As you will see, the Indian domains do better under v.2. So the question is: have Estibot v2 appraisals been inflated, or does Estibot now recognise the value of Indian domains? I believe it's the latter because I also tested out some .com domains and my general observation was that, on Estibot v2, many domains are not being appraised as highly as before (which probably means v2 is more realistic! ).

Out of interest, I also tested the above-listed names with the .com extension. Here are the results:

Poker.com – v2: $2,300,000 (v1: $2,400,000)
Mails.com - v2: $1,200 (v1: $21,000)
Searching.com - v2: $87,000 (v1: $80,000)
Linkshare.com – v2: $37,000 (v1: $50,000)
Webcam.com - v2: $5,300,000 (v1: $850,000)
Defend.com - v2: $7,000 (v1: $42,000)
Tea.com - v2: $1,200,000 (v1: $730,000)
Leds.com - v2: $69,000 (v1: $110,000)
123.com – v2: $21,000 (v1: $66,000)
Hollywood.com – v2: $1,300,000 (v1: $380,000)

As v2 is still in beta, there's always the possibility that further changes will be made to the algorithm. I notice that on v2, Mails.in is worth more than Mails.com.

Obviously, we shouldn't rely solely on automated appraisals to assess the value of a domain name. We need to consider many other factors.

What are your observations about Estibot v2? Who has tested it out?

Iphones.in appraised at 2700 $ .. me thinks its realistic !

__________________
MBA Projects | Online MBA | MBAs | b-school | Case Study |

domainerin, I don't know if it's your domain, but "iPhone" is a well-known trademark owned by Apple. Apple is known to be very protective of its marks...

Thanx Ceres.

I tried 100 LLL.in with new Beta version as I was more familiar with LLL.in price. Here are my findings:
(i) The earlier version was very liberal in giving estimates. This version is more conservative in their prices. One of my names went from six figures to high four figures.

(ii) The average of those 100 premium LLL.in was ~$700. I think that is what an end-user can pay; Of course if you are trying to sell names using Estibot, based on ones' negotiations skills (or lack of it), you can get more or less then Estbot.

(iii) LLL.in starting with 'I' were on average very close to $1K.

I'll play with it a bit more over the weekends and update you guys.

Have a nice weekend folks.

--Ace

I agree with your analysis of how estibot v2 appraises LLL.ins. I put in about 15 of my LLL.ins and most were appraised low to high $xxx, which i think is totally reasonable for end user sales at this moment. SOme came out at very low $x,xxx. I'm happy that a new version of estibot is about to be rolled out. Makes my membership even more worth it

__________________
My sedo names Start your Campaign!

Thanks Ceres,

I think that the Estibot 2 is a better version for .IN names and as a rough guide (and only a rough guide!) a decent tool for helping to price a name for sale or if you are looking at buying a name in the aftermarket.

I only ran through a small number of my .IN names (approx 50 or so) and most of them came back at between US$2000-3000 for each name with a few between US$900-2000 so that was very close to what I had thought they were worth.

Funny thing is that most of the names I am selling at the moment are .CO.IN names so if they could get that side of Estibot working it would be very handy!

Regards

Ed Keay-Smith
OzDomainer.com

interesting from wiki, lot of others ,
also
Oops, iPhone Trademark Already Taken In China (AAPL)
any idea of india status?
P.S. better to stay away from T.M. whatever the valuation IMO.

__________________
after domains|bamboo|scuba diving |>> business2business .in | history .co.in | Gold.ind.in | silver.org.in | Dravid.com

Yes, iPhone is TM , " Iphones " is generic term though IMO .. Check Iphones.com or Iphones.cctld's

Iphones.ru is on alexa rank 13k with lot of other similar cctld domains.

Even if apple had shut sites down with TM, it would first have to claim the TM with others who have filed suit against them.

I've already decided to gift it to a iphone app development company in India anyway

__________________
MBA Projects | Online MBA | MBAs | b-school | Case Study |

@Ace and Warbux - interesting stats re LLL.in's – thanks!

Yes, Estibot 2.0 seems to have no problem handling third level domains. Hooray!

I don't know if Apple has a registered TM in India for "iPhone." However, in January, Apple filed an objection at the Indian TM Registry re TM application for "i phone" by Reliance Communications. To me, this indicates Apple is claiming prior trademark rights in India for "iPhone" (ie. either registered or common law rights).

I don't know when Estibot 2.0 will come out of Beta, but hopefully it will sooner rather than later! I understand some new features are being introduced, such as end-user leads and a direct match network.

I still think estibot v2 underestimates some .co.ins. I only say this because i put in a few one word .co.ins i own, and no appraisal went above $100...maybe i just have bad .co.ins, but i think a few should have been appraised higher.

__________________
My sedo names Start your Campaign!